Disease Progression Among Untreated HIV-Infected Patients in South Ethiopia: Implications for Patient Care
© Jerene et al 2005
Published: 30 August 2005
The natural course of HIV disease progression among resource-poor patient populations has not been clearly defined.
To describe predictors of HIV disease progression as seen at an outpatient clinic in a resource-limited setting in rural Ethiopia.
This prospective cohort study included all adult HIV patients who visited an outpatient clinic at Arba Minch hospital in South Ethiopia between January 30, 2003 and April 1, 2004. Clinical and hematologic measurements were done at baseline and every 12 weeks thereafter until the patient was transferred, put on antiretroviral therapy, was lost to follow-up, or died. Community agents reported patient status every month.
A district hospital with basic facilities for HIV testing and patient monitoring.
Main Outcome Measures
Death, diagnosis of tuberculosis, and change in disease stage.
We followed 207 patients for a median duration of 19 weeks (range, 0–60 weeks). A total of 132 (64%) of them were in WHO stage III. The overall mortality rate was 46 per 100 person-years of observation (PYO). Mortality increased with advancing disease stage. Diarrhea, oral thrush, and low total lymphocyte count were significant markers of mortality. The incidence of tuberculosis was 9.9 per 100 PYO. Baseline history of easy fatigability and fever were strongly associated with subsequent development of tuberculosis.
The mortality rate and the incidence of tuberculosis in our cohort are among the highest ever reported in sub-Saharan Africa. We identified oral thrush, diarrhea, and total lymphocyte count as predictors of mortality, and easy fatigability and fever as predictors of tuberculosis. The findings have practical implications for patient care in resource-limited settings.
Rates of disease progression in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected patients differ between populations due to differences in viral subtypes, host factors, or the environment. However, our knowledge about the pattern of disease progression in HIV infection in developing countries is limited. The few studies done in Africa and other developing countries show that the rate of disease progression is faster among resource-poor patient populations.[3–6] A recent study from Uganda, however, reported that the rate of disease progression is similar in developed and developing countries. The pattern of disease progression among Ethiopian patients has not been studied.
Moreover, with the availability of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), such studies became impossible for ethical reasons. In South Ethiopia, we started to treat HIV patients with HAART in August 2003. Prior to the start of HAART, HIV-infected patients were registered and followed as part of a clinic to treat opportunistic infections. Here, we present the results from a cohort of HIV patients from south Ethiopia who did not receive HAART. The objective of this study was to describe the natural course of HIV disease progression as seen at an outpatient clinic in a resource-limited setting in rural Ethiopia.
This study was conducted at Arba Minch Hospital (AMH), located 500 km south of Addis Ababa. The hospital has 158 beds and serves a population of nearly 1.5 million.
AMH has been doing HIV counseling and testing since the early 1990s. Since January 2002, the HIV unit has been upgraded to serve as a clinic for opportunistic infections. Since August 2003, antiretroviral therapy (ART) has been given to the patients, following the World Health Organization (WHO) and national recommendations.[8, 9]
Both rapid and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) tests were used for HIV testing. We used an automated hematology analyzer (Sysmex Kx-21; Sysmex Corporation; Kobe, Japan) for the measurement of hematologic parameters. A semi-automatic photometer (Photometer 5010, Version 3.0; RIELE; Berlin, Germany) was used for the clinical chemistry tests.
Patients and Study Design
This was a prospective cohort study. Recruitment into the study began in January 30, 2003 and patients were followed through April 1, 2004. Although ART was introduced in August 2003, recruitment into the treatment was withheld until end of December 2003 when a guideline on the fee scheme was issued by the hospital management. All consenting HIV-positive patients older than 15 years of age and residing within the hospital's catchment area were eligible for the study. Initial assessment included basic sociodemographic variables, past medical history, presenting complaints, history of present illness, physical examination including weight and height, and complete blood cell count (CBC). Chest x-ray and acid-fast bacilli stain (AFB) were done per clinical indication. We defined and categorized tuberculosis according to the National Tuberculosis and Leprosy control manual of Ethiopia.
Staging and Follow-up
We staged patients according to the WHO clinical staging system before doing the laboratory investigations. Symptomatic patients were given treatment according to the specific diagnosis. We scheduled 12-weekly follow-up for all patients unless indicated otherwise. At each regular visit, we interviewed patients for new symptoms and examined for new clinical findings. We also did a CBC at each regular visit.
We employed 2 secondary school graduates with basic training on HIV counseling as community agents to follow the patients at the community level. We assigned each of them to the newly recruited patients with their contact details. The agents visited them monthly and offered home-based counseling and support.
Death, change in clinical stage (for stages I, II, and III), and diagnosis of tuberculosis were the main outcome variables. Death at community level was ascertained through community agents. The data clerk at the clinic reported hospital deaths on patient record. Patients who left the study area permanently were labeled as transferred. Patients were regarded as being in care if they had follow-up or initial visit within the previous 90 days before the end of the study and community agents reported that the patient was alive. Patients were regarded as lost to follow-up if they had not had a visit within the previous 90 days and the responsible community agent reported that the patient was lost. We closed the pre-ART follow-up period between January 1, 2004 and April 1, 2004. We followed 90 days into the ART period until we obtained endpoint measurements on all patients, including those on their 12-weekly appointments. Patients who were put on ART were censored at the date of treatment initiation.
We used SPSS for Windows version 12.0 for data analysis. All completed patient data were entered into SPSS on the same day of examination. Follow-up data were also handled similarly. We evaluated the WHO clinical stage, oral candidiasis (oral thrush), diarrhea, body mass index (BMI), total lymphocyte count (TLC), and hemoglobin (Hgb) as predictors of death in our patients. The TLC was treated as a dichotomous variable at a cut-off value of 1200 cells/mL because of its clinical significance for the initiation of ART. Similarly, we used the cut-off value 18.5 kg/m2 for BMI. Because we do not have normal values for Hgb in the study area, we used an arbitrary cut-off value of 10 g/dL for both men and women. This is the cut-off value below which treatment with zidovudine-containing regimen is not recommended. All of the clinical symptoms were treated as dichotomous variables.
We used the Kaplan-Meier method to determine the event-free survival, and the log-rank test was used to assess the statistical significance. In order to determine the relative risk for death we used the Cox-regression method. The hazard ratio (HR) was used to determine the difference in the relative risk for death, and it was described as 95% confidence interval (95% CI). We calculated death rates as death per 100 PYO.
A patient was considered to have progressed to the next highest WHO stage provided that he or she presented with a new stage-defining event at 12 weeks or later following the initial examination. The date of staging was considered the date of progression. We estimated the rate of disease progression by the Kaplan-Meier method for patients in stages I, II, and III.
Tuberculosis incidence was calculated as number of tuberculosis cases per 100 PYO. We calculated 95% CIs of rates and rate ratios of tuberculosis incidence assuming Poisson distribution of tuberculosis occurrence. All patients were considered to be at risk of developing tuberculosis during follow-up. Patients already on treatment were also considered at risk because of the risk of reinfection. We evaluated fever, easy fatigability, cough, past history of tuberculosis, TLC ≤ 1200/mL, and WHO stage as possible predictors of tuberculosis by the Kaplan-Meier and Cox-regression methods as described above.
Proportions of relevant variables were compared using the chi-squared test. Statistical tests were considered significant if the 2-sided P value was <.05.
The study protocol was approved by the National Ethics Review Committee in Ethiopia and by the Regional Committee for Medical Research Ethics in Western Norway. HIV testing was done after informed written consent following a pretest counseling session. Patients were offered the available treatment irrespective of their consent to participate in the study. It is not the Ethiopian policy to give isoniazid (INH) prophylaxis to adult HIV-infected patients.
We enrolled and followed 207 patients between January 30, 2003 and April 1, 2004. A total of 191 (92%) patients came from urban areas, mostly (168 patients, 81%) from Arba Minch town. Their median age was 30 years (range, 17–75 years). More than one third of the patients were divorced, widowed, or separated. Almost one third were unemployed, and one third had no formal education. A quarter of them came with a letter of exemption from fee for medical services, and their mean monthly income was about US$26.
Clinical Characteristics at Initial Examination
Distribution of Patients in Each WHO Stage at Presentation, Arba Minch Hospital, 2004
Number of Patients
Additionally, 45 (19%) patients had a past or present history of herpes zoster and 46 (22%) patients gave past history of at least 1 episode of tuberculosis. At enrolment, 55 (27%) patients either were on treatment for tuberculosis or were diagnosed to have tuberculosis. Smear-negative pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB-) was the most common type (30 of 55 patients, 54%), followed by smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB+; 11 out of 55 patients, 20%), extrapulmonary tuberculosis (EPTB; 9 out of 55 patients, 16%), and unspecified in 5 out of 55 patients (9%).
The median duration of follow-up was 19 weeks (range, 0–60 weeks). By the end of the study, 47 (23%) patients had died, 11 (5%) patients were lost to follow-up, 9 (4%) were transferred to another health institution, 51 (25%) were put on ART, and 89 (43%) were under regular follow-up and not yet put on ART.
Hazard Ratio (HR) of Death According to Different Cox-Regression Analyses, Arba Minch Hospital, 2004
Univariate Analysis(HR [95% CI])
Multivariate Analysis(HR [95% CI])
Oral thrush (yes vs no)
TLC (≤ 1200/mL vs > 1200/mL)
Hgb (≤ 10 g/dL vs > 10 g/dL)
WHO stage (III–IV vs I–II)
Diarrhea (yes vs no)
BMI (< 18.5 kg/m2 vs ≥ 18.5 kg/m2)
Incidence of Tuberculosis
Ten patients (5 men and 5 women) developed tuberculosis during follow-up. One patient developed PTB+, 2 developed EPTB, and the other 7 were PTB-cases. The overall incidence rate of tuberculosis was 10 cases/101.3 PYO = 9.9 cases per 100 PYO (95% CI, 8.1–12.0). The incidence rate was higher in patients with stage III and IV disease (8/70.5 PYO = 11.4 per 100 PYO) than stage I and II combined (2/30.9 PYO = 6.5 per 100 PYO), but the difference was not statistically significant (incidence rate ratio = 1.8; 95% CI = 0.4–8.2). Patients with baseline history of easy fatigability (chi-squared = 16.8, P <.001) and fever (chi-squared = 22.0, P <.001) were more likely to develop tuberculosis during follow-up. There was no significant association with past history of tuberculosis (chi-squared = 3.2, P =.073; log-rank test).
Hazard Ratio (HR) for Tuberculosis Incidence According to Different Cox-Regression Analyses, Arba Minch Hospital, 2004
Univariate Analysis(HR [95% CI])
Multivariate Analysis(HR [95% CI])
Fever (yes vs no)
Weakness (yes vs no)
Cough (yes vs no)
Past history of TB (yes vs no)
WHO stage (III–IV vs I–II)
Change in Clinical Stages
Only 9 patients progressed to a higher disease stage during follow-up – 5 from stage I to II, 2 from stage II to III, 1 from III to IV, and 1 progressed directly from stage I to III. Evidence for progression from stage I to II were weight loss between 5% and 10% of body weight in 4 cases, and repeated upper respiratory tract infection in 1 patient. Patients with initial stage I disease had the highest risk of a new stage-defining event (log-rank test; chi-squared = 21, P <.001).
In this study, we found a very high mortality rate and a very high incidence of tuberculosis. We identified oral thrush and low TLC as strong predictors of death among our patients. Baseline history of easy fatigability and fever predicted subsequent development of tuberculosis. The risk of new stage-defining event was highest among patients with stage I disease. Additionally, we identified silky hair as a sign of advanced HIV disease.
However, the findings should be interpreted cautiously because of some limitations in the study design. The short follow-up period did not allow us to measure the long-term disease progression pattern in our patients. Because of limited facilities, our diagnosis depended primarily on the clinical picture. We also did not attempt to determine the date of HIV infection in our patients, and hence it does not describe the full picture of the natural history of HIV infection. However, the findings of our study may be representative of the actual situation in resource-limited settings as we followed patients during routine activities in the clinic. We also gathered reliable information about the outcome of our patients because of the community agents.
A mortality rate of 46 per 100 PYO in our cohort is probably among the highest ever reported in sub-Saharan Africa. The high proportion of patients with advanced disease, the high magnitude of comorbid clinical conditions, and the high death detection rate by community agents probably contributed to the high mortality rate. In other hospital-based studies from Africa, mortality in the absence of HAART ranged from 10 to 35 per 100 PYO. As a comparison, a community-based study in south-central Ethiopia showed a crude mortality rate of 11.2 per 1000 PYO among adults.
Most of the incidence data for TB come from developed countries.[15, 16] From Africa, we have only limited data. An incidence rate of 9.9 per 100 PYO in our study is about 10 times higher than that reported from a research clinic in Ethiopia. Ours is in agreement with a report of 10.4 per 100 PYO from Cape Town. Most of our patients came from low socioeconomic backgrounds where tuberculosis is rampant even without HIV. Because we used clinical criteria, overdiagnosis of PTB-cases could have contributed to the high incidence. However, because the data were collected under real-life situations at a district hospital, it is likely to represent the actual tuberculosis situation. Although easy fatigability and prolonged low-grade fever are often described as nonspecific symptoms of tuberculosis, patients with these symptoms may require more frequent monitoring for tuberculosis.
Presence of diarrhea remained a significant marker of death in patients with stages III and IV disease. Because diarrhea is an easily recognizable symptom, history of diarrhea should always be determined during clinical examinations even when other stage-defining events are present. Whether diarrhea could predict mortality in patients receiving ART needs further evaluation. Further studies should also attempt to identify definitive causes of diarrhea and their prognostic values in such settings.
Several authors have described the prognostic value of oral candidiasis, BMI, TLC, and anemia.[19–25] We further confirm the prognostic value of oral thrush and low TLC but not of BMI and hemoglobin levels in patients who are not receiving ART. Additionally, we found that the mortality rate was higher in patients with oral candidiasis within the same WHO stage. The WHO now recommends initiation of ART for all patients in stage III if there are no facilities for performing CD4+ cell counts. In settings with scarce resources, priority should be given to patients with oral thrush.
Some authors reported silky hair (the "straight hair sign") as a sign of HIV infection, while others argued that it is not pathognomonic for HIV infection.[26–28] Its pathogenesis is not known but some reported it as being a manifestation of mitochondrial abnormality. Although there are no published reports from Ethiopia, silky hair is included as a minor sign in the Ethiopian AIDS case definition. This sign is not included in the WHO staging system. Because more than a quarter of our patients with stage III and IV disease had silky hair, we suggest that it be included as a sign of advanced HIV infection in African patient populations. Whether the hair changes to its normal status with ART needs further investigation.
The apparent high risk for change in disease stage among asymptomatic patients could be due to the minor weight loss, which could occur with similar frequency in both HIV-positive and HIV-negative individuals as reported from Uganda. Minor weight loss and pulmonary tuberculosis were the most commonly diagnosed conditions among HIV-positive individuals in Ethiopia. In a multicountry study, no difference was found between stages I and II.[32, 33] Moreover, the low risk for progression among patients in advanced stage could be due to the high mortality that probably occurred before any evidence of stage change.
In conclusion, we identified simple clinical and laboratory markers as predictors of death and tuberculosis occurrence. Identifying the specific stage-defining conditions could be of practical importance for patient counseling and for clinical decision-making in resource-limited settings. The prognostic value of these markers in patients receiving ART needs further investigation. History of easy fatigability and fever should be asked routinely in HIV-positive patients in order to identify patients at immediate risk of developing clinical tuberculosis. These symptoms could also identify patients who might benefit from tuberculosis prophylactic therapy. We recommend that INH prophylaxis be included as part of the standard package of care for Ethiopian HIV-infected patients.
The HIV/AIDS project of AMH was funded by the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation (NORAD).
Authors and Disclosures
Degu Jerene, MD, has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
Bernt Lindtjørn, MD, PhD, has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
We thank Samuel Mamo and Temesgen Girmaye for performing the laboratory tests. We are grateful to Dr. Yewubnesh Hailu for participating in the recruitment of patients. We are also grateful to Asnakech Abayneh, the data clerk, and to Tesfalem Babena and Feven Fetene, the community agents, for their excellent work in tracing and recording patient information. Tamirat Seyoum, Tolosa Tomas, and Tadele Roba did most of the counseling.
- Hogan CM, Hammer SM: Host determinants in HIV infection and disease. Part 2: Genetic factors and implications for antiretroviral therapeutics. Ann Intern Med 2001, 134: 978–996. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jaffar S, Grant AD, Whitworth JW, Smith PG, Whittle H: The natural history of HIV-1 and HIV-2 infections in adults in Africa: a literature review. Bull World Health Organ 2004, 82: 462–469. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Deschamps MM, Fitzgerald DW, Pape JW, Johnson D: HIV infection in Haiti: natural history and disease progression. AIDS 2000, 14: 2515–2521. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anzala OA, Nagelkerke NJ, Bwayo JJ, et al.: Rapid progression to disease in African sex workers with human immunodeficiency type 1 infection. J Infect Dis 1995, 171: 686–689. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Morgan D, Malamba SS, Orem J, Mayanja B, Okongo M, Whitworth JAG: Survival by AIDS defining condition in rural Uganda. Sex Transm Infect 2000, 76: 193–197. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Morgan D, Mahe C, Mayanja B, Whitworth J: Progression to symptomatic disease in people infected with HIV-1 in rural Uganda: prospective cohort study. BMJ 2002, 324: 193–197. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Morgan D, Mahe C, Mayanja B, Okongo JM, Lubega R, Whitworth JAG: HIV-1 infection in rural Africa: is there a difference in median time to AIDS and survival compared with that in industrialized countries? AIDS 2002, 16: 597–603.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- World Health Organization: Scaling-up antiretroviral therapy in resource-limited settings. [http://www.who.int/docstore/hiv/scaling/guidelines.pdf] Guidelines for a public health approach Geneva: World Health Organization; 2002. Accessed July 29, 2005Google Scholar
- Ministry of Health/HIV/AIDS Prevention and Control Office/Drug Administration and Control Authority: Guidelines for use of antiretroviral drugs in Ethiopia. [http://cnhde.ei.columbia.edu/files/4/3/2004-Dec-Thu-074644] Addis Ababa 2003. Accessed July 29, 2005Google Scholar
- Ministry of Health: National TB and Leprosy Control Manual. Addis Ababa: Ministry of Health; 2002.Google Scholar
- World Health Organization: Acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS): interim proposal for a WHO staging system for HIV-1 infection and disease. Wkly Epidemiol Rec 1990, 65: 221–228. AbstractGoogle Scholar
- Food and Agriculture Organization: Body Mass Index – A measure of chronic energy deficiency in adults. Food and Nutrition Paper 56. Food and Agriculture Organization 1994.Google Scholar
- Betty RK, Jonathan AC: Essential Medical Statistics. 2nd edition. London: Blackwell Publishing Ltd; 2003.Google Scholar
- Berhane Y, Hogberg U, Byass P, Wall S: Gender, literacy and survival among Ethiopian adults, 1987–96. Bull World Health Organ 2002, 80: 714–720. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Moreno S, Baraia-Etxaburu J, Bouza E, et al.: Risk for developing tuberculosis among anergic patients infected with HIV. Ann Intern Med 1993, 119: 194–198. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Markowitz N, Hansen NI, Hopewell PC, et al.: Incidence of tuberculosis in the United States among HIV-infected persons. Ann Intern Med 1997, 126: 123–132. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wood R, Maartens G, Lombard CJ: Risk factors for developing tuberculosis in HIV-1-infected adults from communities with a low or very high incidence of tuberculosis. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 2000, 23: 75–80. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wolday D, Hailu B, Girma M, Hailu E, Sanders E, Fontanet A: Low CD4+ cell count and high HIV viral load precede the development of tuberculosis disease in a cohort of HIV-positive Ethiopians. Ethiop Med J 2003, 41 (suppl 1) : 67–73. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hilton JF: Functions of oral candidiasis episodes those are highly prognostic for AIDS. Statist Med 2000, 19: 989–1004.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hilton JF, Alves M, Anastos K, et al.: Accuracy of diagnoses of HIV-related oral lesions by medical clinicians. Findings from the Women's Interagency HIV Study. Commun Dent Oral Epidemiol 2001, 29: 362–372.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nittayananta W, Chanowanna N, Sripatanakul S, Winn T: Risk factors associated with oral lesions in HIV-infected heterosexual people and intravenous drug users in Thailand. J Oral Pathol Med 2001, 30: 224–230. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Campo J, Del Romero J, Castilla J, Garcia S, Rodriguez C, Bascones A: Oral candidiasis as a clinical marker related to viral load, CD4 lymphocyte count and CD4 lymphocyte percentage in HIV-infected patients. J Oral Pathol Med 2002, 31: 5–10. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yared M, Nicole HD, Eduard S, et al.: Simple markers for initiating antiretroviral therapy among HIV-infected Ethiopians [Concise communication]. AIDS 2003, 362: 1625–1627.Google Scholar
- Mofenson L, Harries D, Moye J, et al.: Alternatives to HIV-1 RNA concentration and CD4 count to predict mortality in HIV-1-infected children in resource-poor settings [Letter]. Lancet 2003, 362: 1625–1627. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bryan L, Stephen JG, John PP, Sharon AR, Roger D, Joseph BM: Rapid declines in total lymphocyte counts and haemoglobin concentration prior to AIDS among HIV-1 infected men. AIDS 2003, 17: 2035–2044. AbstractView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kinchelow T, Schimidt V, Ignato S: Changes in the hair of black patients with AIDS [Letter]. J Infect Dis 1988, 157: 394.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Leonidas JR: Hair alterations in black patients with the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome. Cutis 1987, 39: 537–538. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Stephen LG, Douglas LN: Straightening of the hair is not pathognomonic for HIV infection [Correspondence]. Clin Infect Dis 2002, 35: 1276–1277. AbstractGoogle Scholar
- Bodemer C, Rotig A, Rustin P, et al.: Hair and skin disorders as signs of mitochondrial disease. Pediatrics 1999, 103: 428–433. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ministry of Health: Guidelines for clinical management of HIV infection in adults in Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: Ministry of Health; 2000.Google Scholar
- Kassa E, Rinke de Wit TF, Hailu E, et al.: Evaluation of the World Health Organization staging system for HIV infection and disease in Ethiopia: association between clinical stages and laboratory markers. AIDS 1999, 13: 381–389. AbstractView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dennis HO: Classification and staging of HIV Infection. [http://hivinsite.ucsf.edu/InSite?=kb-01-01] HIV InSite Knowledge Base Chapter 1998. Accessed July 29, 2005Google Scholar
- Lifson AR, Allen S, Wolf W, et al.: Classification of HIV infection and disease in women from Rwanda: evaluation of the World Health Organization HIV staging system and recommended modifications. Ann Intern Med 1995, 122: 262–270. AbstractPubMedGoogle Scholar